Who Needs Controlled Vocabularies When We Have Keywords & Free Text Searching?
Aim
Aim of this paper is to compare keyword searching in Hrčak: Portal of Croatian scientific and professional journals and subject searching in library catalogues.
Methods
Methods used in this research include content analysis and comparison. The research will be done in two phases. The first phase is to analyse Guidelines for authors of 54 active journals in the field of Biomedicine and Healthcare included in Hrčak in order to find out what type of instructions are given to authors regarding the creation of the keywords for the manuscript prepared for the selected journal. In the second phase, research will be done following 4 steps 1. step is to choose a sample of articles from the journals with keywords made by using MeSH thesaurus. All data will be collected into a table with journal title, article title, abstract and keywords. 2. step is to identify all synonyms and all keywords within articles around a similar subject (e.g. abortion, miscarriage). 3. step is to make searches using all variations of terms used by authors (e.g. synonyms and close synonyms) and compare the results in order to see how results are changed if different keywords for the same subject. 4. step is to extract an exhaustive list of Main Heading (Descriptor) Terms and Entry terms from the MeSH thesaurus in order to compare a) authors’ keywords extracted from chosen articles and subject headings from library catalogue assigned to the same articles.
Chosen research topics are abortion and homosexuality (including all keywords closely connected to those terms). Extraction, analysis and keywords test searches will be done only in English and only English keywords examples will be included in the sample of the study.
Results and Discussion
Analysis of Author’s guidelines from 54 journals will give an overview of what is expected from authors on how to approach the keywords creation task. The field of Biomedicine and Healthcare were chosen because it was noticed that some (almost all) journals either suggest or ‘prescribe’ usage of the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) Index Medicus for keywords (1). In literature review, several approaches to keyword creation can be identified. In most cases, authors themselves choose usually around six keywords which best describe topics of their article (2). Also, sometimes authors have to choose keywords from the existing list (e.g. MeSH). Some examples included automatic abstracting and keyword extraction and another approach is to give that task to a professional indexer, i.e. librarian to the subject indexing/keyword assigning to articles. Keywords are usually not controlled but it would help if they are connected, at least making possible to collocate similar subject areas. On the other hand, subject headings are controlled and often not understandable to regular users. There is a need for controlled vocabularies in the catalogues, since keyword searching retrieves only part of results when there are no subject headings included (3). Research showed that keywords provided by authors have an important presence in database descriptors (4). It is a great challenge to find satisfactory solutions which will provide the best possible search results for both users of Hrčak and library catalogues.
Conclusion
In order to give more reliable resources and attract more (happy and satisfied) users, the Editorial Board of Hrčak Portal should rethink Hrčak’s indexing and search options. There is always an option of a free text searching, but the results of that usually end up with more results and more (un)useful results. On the other hand, journals should think wheatear they should employ professionals to deal with keywords (i.e. information scientists) or introduce controlled vocabulary (thesaurus, subject heading lists) for indexing their articles in order to enhance recall of the more relevant results through existing search options. Since there are interesting and innovative approaches to the representation of the article’s content, journals and Hrčak should consider creating word clouds for an article or even an issue or volume of the journal. Visualization of the content could help in better usage of articles, i.e. journals included in Hrčak.
- Gwen FranckEIFL, Lithuania
Gwen Franck is consultant and facilitator, interested in the ‘hands on’ aspects of Open Science such open access publishing, self-archiving… More →
- Victoria TsoukalaEuropean Commission
Victoria Tsoukala works as a Policy Officer in the European Commission, DG RTD.G2: Open Science, in Secondment from her position at the… More →
- Adriaan van der WeelLeiden University
Adriaan van der Weel is Bohn extraordinary professor of Modern Dutch Book History at the University of Leiden and lecturer in Book and… More →
- Sami SyrjämäkiFederation of Finnish Learned Societies
Dr Sami Syrjämäki is the head of publications at the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies. His expert work focuses on science policies… More →
- Thed van LeeuwenLeiden University
Thed van Leeuwen is a senior researcher at the Centre for Science and Technology Studies (CWTS) of Leiden University in the Netherlands. As… More →
- Andrei RostovtsevDissernet, Russia
Prof Andrei Rostovtsev is a Russian physicist, doctor of physical and mathematical sciences. He graduated from the National Research Nuclear… More →
- Vanessa ProudmanSPARC Europe
Vanessa Proudman is Director of SPARC Europe; she is working to make Open the default in Europe. Vanessa has 20 years’ international… More →
- Ana MarušićUniversity of Split
Ana Marušić is Professor of Anatomy and Chair of the Department of Research in Biomedicine and Health at the University of Split School of… More →
- Alen VodopijevecRuđer Bošković Institute
MSc Alen Vodopijevec obtained his diploma in 2003 at the University of Zagreb, Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, and currently is… More →
- Anita Pavić Pintarić
- Damien VannsonThunken
Builder at heart, driven by the satisfaction of turning shower thoughts and back-of-the-envelope plans into full-fledged, user-friendly… More →
- Danijel GudeljUniversity of Zagreb
Danijel Gudelj is M.A. of sociology and croatology, graduated at Centre for Croatian Studies, University of Zagreb. Currently, he is a… More →
- Blaž RebernjakUniversity of Zagreb
Blaž Rebernjak was born in Zagreb in 1983, where he finished primary and secondary schools. In 2007 he obtained his MA and in 2013 his PhD… More →
- Evgenia Arh
- Drahomira CuparUniversity of Zadar
Drahomira Cupar, Phd, is an assistant professor at the University of Zadar, Department of Information Sciences. She obtained her PhD in… More →
- Elizabeth WagerSideview
Elizabeth (Liz) Wager, PhD is a freelance consultant and trainer who has worked on six continents. She chaired the Committee on Publication… More →
- Filip HorvatUniversity of Rijeka
Filip Horvat is a librarian at the Faculty of Civil Engineering, University of Rijeka. He received his Master’s degree in Information… More →
- Goranka MitrovićNational and University Library in Zagreb
Goranka Mitrović, senior librarian, works at the National and University Library in Zagreb, Croatia (NUL) since 1993. Her research interest… More →
- Draženko CeljakUniversity Computing Centre
MSc Draženko Celjak is the head of data services at SRCE – University of Zagreb University Computing Centre. He coordinates and leads the… More →
- Iva Melinščak ZlodiUniversity of Zagreb
Iva Melinščak Zlodi works as an e-resources librarian at the Library of the University of Zagreb Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences… More →
- Ivana MajerUniversity of Zagreb
Ivana Majer graduated from the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences at the University of Zagreb, and got her degree in Croatian… More →
- Irena KranjecUniversity of Zagreb
Irena Kranjec works as a subject librarian for information sciences at the Library of the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences… More →
- Jasminka MaravićCARNet Department for Education Support
Jasminka Maravić is Project Manager at CARNet Department for Education Support. During her 14 years in CARNet she has been involved in… More →
- Krešimir ZauderUniversity of Zadar
Krešimir Zauder was born in Zagreb, Croatia in 1980. He graduated Information science and English language and literature in 2006. In 201… More →
- Jure TriglavCollaborative Knowledge Foundation
Jure is the lead developer at the Collaborative Knowledge Foundation, where he develops the PubSweet framework and supports its community. More →
- Josipa Zetović
- Kristina RomićNational and University Library in Zagreb
Kristina Romić works at the Acquisition Department, National and University Library in Zagreb, Croatia. She graduated from the Faculty of… More →
- Ksenija Baždarić
- Ksenija Švenda RadeljakUniversity of Zagreb
Ksenija Švenda Radeljak is employed at the Library of Department of Social Work at the Faculty of Law University in Zagreb. The areas of her… More →
- Linda SīleUniversity of Antwerp
Linda Sīle is doctoral student at the University of Antwerp within the Centre for R&D Monitoring (ECOOM). My current work spans somewhat… More →
- Lovela Machala PoplašenUniversity of Zagreb
Lovela Machala Poplašen is a head librarian at the Andrija Štampar Library, School of Public Health, School of Medicine, University of… More →
- Ljiljana Poljak
- Luc BorutaThunken
Ph.D. in computational linguistics, natural language processor, interested in linked data and linguistic diversity. In previous lives, Luc… More →
- Ljiljana Jertec MusapSRCE – University Computing Centre, University of Zagreb
MSc Ljiljana Jertec is a librarian and computer specialist at SRCE – University of Zagreb University Computing Centre. She has a Master’s… More →
- Lucija VejmelkaUniversity of Zagreb
Lucija Vejmelka is an assistant professor at the University of Zagreb, Faculty of Law, Department of Social Works, where she leads the… More →
- Marijana Briški Gudelj
- Marijana GlavicaUniversity of Zagreb
MSc Marijana Glavica works as a systems librarian at the University of Zagreb Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences Library, where she… More →
- Marina Cvitanušić BrečićCroatian Agency for Science and Higher Education
Marina Cvitanušić Brečić works at the Analytics and Statistics Department of the Croatian Agency for Science and Higher Education (ASHE… More →
- Marina GrubišićCroatian Agency for Science and Higher Education
Marina Grubišić is the head of the Analytics and Statistics Department of the Croatian Agency for Science and Higher Education (ASHE). She… More →
- Matko MarušićUniversity of Split
Matko Marušić is Professor Emeritus at the University of Split, Split, Croatia. He was a Professor at Medical Schools (in Zagreb and Split… More →
- Nicolas Robinson-Garcia
- Neven Pintarić
- Paulin RibbeOpenEdition
Paulin Ribbe is Project Manager for the OPERAS infrastructure at OpenEdition (France, Marseille - CNRS, AMU, EHESS, Avignon Univ.). He holds… More →
- Radovan VranaUniversity of Zagreb
Born in Zagreb, Croatia. Primary and secondary education completed in Zagreb. Croatia. Graduated information sciences and the English… More →
- Rafaelly StavaleUniversity of Brasília
Rafaelly Stavale is a current student of Nursing at Universidade de Brasília – UnB. She has recently completed the Principles and Practices… More →
- Olga KirillovaAssociation of Science Editors and Publishers (ASEP), Moscow, Russia
Olga V. Kirillova, Candidate of Science (Engineering, 2004), the President of the Association of Science Editors and Publishers (ASEP, since… More →
- Pierre MounierOpenEdition
Pierre Mounier is deputy director of OpenEdition , a comprehensive infrastructure based in France for open access publication and… More →
- Rodrigo CostasLeiden University
Rodrigo Costas is an experienced researcher in the field of information science and bibliometrics. With a PhD in Library and Information… More →
- Tihana RubićUniversity of Zagreb
Tihana Rubić is an assistant professor at the Department of Ethnology and Cultural Anthropology, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences… More →
- Vicko TomićUniversity of Split
Vicko Tomić is a research assistant at the Department of Research in Biomedicine and Health at the University of Split School of Medicine… More →
- Vanessa FairhurstCrossref
Vanessa Fairhurst joined Crossref in 2017 and is based at the Oxford office. As Community Outreach Manager, her role involves working… More →
- Želimir KurtanjekUniversity of Zagreb
Želimir Kurtanjek is a retired professor of chemical engineering with an interest in biotechnology, biostatistics and big data analytics… More →
- Vlatka BožičevićUniversity of Zagreb
Vlatka Božičević gratuated from Religious Pedagogy and Catechetics at the Catholic Faculty of Theology University of Zagreb and the… More →
- Željka Salopek
- Zoran VelagićUniversity of Osijek
Zoran Velagić is a professor of book history and publishing studies at the University of Osijek, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences… More →